The customer service I received while selling my pendent through Diamond Lighthouse was top-notch from beginning to end. Melissa Hill did such a great job updating me as new offers came in to sell my... See more
Companies on Trustpilot aren't allowed to offer incentives or pay to hide reviews.
See what reviewers are saying
I have never sold anything online and was leery about using Diamond Lighthouse, however, each step of the process was professional and easy. Melissa helped make everything go as smoothly as possible.... See more
Selling a diamond is a little bit of a bummer because the retail price of diamonds is so inflated that reselling them is depressing as a consumer. It's hard to see the diamond industries clever... See more
Company replied
Selling a diamond that is practically brand new came with a lot of sadness but also a blessing in disguise. I found Diamondlighthouse online and never really hesitated to deal with them. They called... See more
Company details
Information provided by various external sources
Our experienced and friendly customer service staff is here to assist you! We will guide you every step of the way in selling your diamond, answering all your questions and offering sound advice.
Contact info
15 West 47th Street, Suite 1006, 10036, New York
- (212) 221-3278
- info@diamondlighthouse.com
- diamondlighthouse.com
Excellent service
Trustworthy, prompt, friendly, expert service. Easy to contact, amazingly quick response. The best service I have ever received. I would recommend this company to everyone. They stay in communication with you and explain every step. More than happy with the outcome.
First time selling diamonds
Diamond Lighthouse was selected after reading a few reviews.
Filled out necessary info and had Tania follow up with the way things were to proceed.
In short the entire process and transaction was as Tania described.
4 offers were received within a few days with the 4th being the final which I accepted.
Payment followed within 2 days with Tania following up to confirm receipt of payment.
Diamond Lighthouse acted in a most professional manner and I will use them again if and when the opportunity arises.
Easy to use, quick to sell
This company was very easy to work with. Everything is completed with total transparency so you should have no hesitancy sending your jewelry to them.
Great customer service
Easy process, very good experience, no issues at all.
They made this so easy
I was apprehensive about selling my diamond on line but Diamond Lighthouse made me feel very secure every step of the way. They were transparency itself. My stone was sold, the money in my account, everything happened just like they said it would. They called and e-mailed frequently to be sure I was aware of what was going on. I would deal with them again in a minute.
Effortless
Diamond Lighthouse handled the selling of my ring smooth, easy, and effortlessly. Any questions I had there was always someone available to answer them. They kept me updated every step of the way with their great online portal. I would use them in a heartbeat to sell any of my diamonds. Totally professional and trustworthy.
Easy and Fair
Selling a diamond is a little bit of a bummer because the retail price of diamonds is so inflated that reselling them is depressing as a consumer. It's hard to see the diamond industries clever supply and demand tactics reflected in your own wallet.
Overlooking that single aspect, doing business with Diamond Lighthouse was a breeze! The process was very simple and straightforward. The only hiccup I encountered was I never received the video of my diamond being appraised, which would have been comforting to watch.
I received 5 or so offers and took the last one. I suspect the offers aren't really from other agencies, but merely a negotiation tactic to get you excited to sell your diamond. Nevertheless, the less than 25% of what I paid retail for the ring didn't shock me and I accepted the offer. Additionally, I was told that a melting fee was "waived" when it was later revealed that the buyer was simply going to purchase the ring as is and not just the diamond. I thought that was a bit dishonest, but I suppose that's to be expected as well.
Moral of the story: selling a diamond sucks, but doing it through Diamond Lighthouse is a pretty easy process. Good luck!

Reply from Diamond Lighthouse
Flawless Experience From Start to Finish!
I traveled to NYC because I was very skeptical to send my wedding ring and wedding band by mail to a company that I had found online. I figured that by going in person I could make a better call to see if I could truly trust them with my valuables. They explained the process to me thoroughly and not only did I feel assured that my diamond was in safe hands- I left confident that they would get me the most money for my ring. Within a couple of days I had a great offer which surpassed my expectations! If I were to do it again though, I would save the money on the trip and have mailed it directly to them. The staff is not only extremely friendly but they know how to do their job well. I couldn't have had a more positive experience with Diamond Lighthouse from start to finish.
Selling a loose diamond
I'm not going to lie, the fact that I had to blindly trust a company and ship my diamond to them, was very frightening. Melissa reassured me every step of the way. I was relieved when it was delivered. The process of evaluating my diamond, was just as indicated on their website. They really do take all the steps necessary, to put your mind at ease and to assure that there is no shady practices taking place.
In the end, I didn't sell my diamond and the return process was just as efficient as the beginning process.
I would, without a doubt, use Diamond Lighthouse again and would highly recommend them to anyone with the need to sell their jewelry.
Excellent
That was a exelente experience to sell our daimond for the 100% for the value others company's they offer 20% the most the 50% if you are lucky thank you
Luis
Great company!
Excellent service by Melissa! Questions are answered immediately and the service was outstanding. Would definitely use Diamond Lighthouse again and highly recommend them! They really do a great job of getting you the highest price possible for your diamond. Very satisfied.
Great way to easily sell diamonds!
I have never sold anything online and was leery about using Diamond Lighthouse, however, each step of the process was professional and easy. Melissa helped make everything go as smoothly as possible. I had a small issue with my check that was issued, but Melissa responded quickly and swiftly and the problem was taken care of immediately. I would use them again!
Diamond Lighthouse
My experience with Diamond Lighthouse was excellent. The professionals at the company did everything advertised to get me the most for my diamond!
Excellant Company for selling your Memories
This company was great in the aide of helping me sell one of my diamond pieces. They worked with me to give me the best price possible and even asked for my opinions of what I would be expecting from them. They actually do care and Melissa was great to work with. If I do have other pieces I would highly recommend this company to anyone as I would be more than happy to work with them again!
Painless, easy way to see your diamond jewelry
I was very happy with my experience with Diamond Lighthouse. Everything was handled quickly and professionally. I would definitely recommend them to a friend!
Would recommend this company to anyone.
I was a bit hesitant and skeptical to use an online company to sell my diamond, but after shopping around I settled on Diamond Lighthouse. The experience went smoothly and was handled very professionally. Melissa's customer service was terrific and I am very pleased with the offer I received.
excellent service
My experience with Melissa was very good. She kept me informed and answered all questions in a timely manner. Though I chose not to sell my ring she handled it very professional. My experience was excellent.
No Problems
My Father-in-Law recommended this to me. I was honestly skeptical at first but Melissa and her team were very helpful and put mind mind at ease. The evaluation was very thorough and any questions I had were answered.
Excellent
Working with Melissa was wonderful! She was always available and if not someone else always was. My diamond was sold in a record amount of time and payment was received within 2 days. Overall is was an excellent experience and I would recommend them to ANYONE looking to sell their diamonds! Thanks girls!!!
When dealing with a professional copany you expect professionalism, however when dealing with Melissa at Diamond Lighthouse you get so much more--you get kindness.
At 72 years old, I had no idea what to expect in trying to sell my wedding rings in order to purchase a new ring for my Mattie. This is when an unexpected event occurred. Melissa at Diamond Lighthouse greeted me and her professionalism was present in our conversation. Her kindness was the unexpected in her voice.
She guided me through the events that would occur over the next few days, and they occurred exactly as she said. Not too many times in my life had I heard a voice with a smile on it, and this was one of them.
Great job, Melissa, you keep smiling, it warms the heart of an old man at the other end of the line.
Edd Freeman
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Labeled Verified, they’re about genuine experiences.
Learn more about other kinds of reviews.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







