Absolutely disgraceful service from The AA – ignored, overcharged, misled
I booked front and rear brake replacement with The AA's Smart Care service for 27 June 2025. Total quoted: £490.31 + VAT, spread via finance provider Payment Assist.
On the day, the mobile mechanic only completed the rear brakes, citing a "seized component" on the front and an inability to source the necessary part (despite the breaks having been completely disassembled a few months prior - with no issues - for a service & MOT). He reinstalled my original front brakes and told me I could rebook or take the car elsewhere — and explicitly stated I'd only be charged for work done.
I immediately called AA Customer Services and spoke to 'AJ', who told me I would only receive a partial refund of ~£120 for the uncompleted front brake job — which was quoted at £249.66 + VAT. I disputed this and AJ wasn't able to do anything, and said he’d escalate to a supervisor and I’d get a call on Monday.
That call never came.
I sent a formal complaint the same day by email The AA, copied to Payment Assist, clearly outlining the situation and requesting the invoice be corrected to reflect only the rear brake job. I received no response at all from the AA and, despite multiple follow-ups, The AA never acknowledged any of my subsequent emails. Absolutely abysmal customer service.
I phoned again a few days later given none of my emails were being acknowledged by The AA, and spoke to Niall. He reviewed the case and had to confer with multiple colleagues, including AJ and 'Kirsten', before finally agreeing that I should only be charged for the rear brake work. Initially, even Niall said a partial reduction had already been sent to Payment Assist, but this was still incorrect.
He eventually confirmed the correct figure - I wasn't giving in to their foolishness...
Niall also told me that Kirsten from the AA had already contacted Payment Assist, but crucially, not me, the actual customer. That was confirmed — no email, no call, no direct contact from anyone at the AA.
According to AA Smart Care Terms & Conditions (v. Sept 2023):
“You will only be charged for the products and/or services that are actually provided.”
“You will not be charged for any additional work that you have not authorised.”
Despite this, I was initially told I’d only receive a partial refund for work that was neither completed nor authorised — a clear contradiction of their own published Terms.
Had I not repeatedly escalated this and challenged the responses, The AA would have left the overcharge in place, in violation of both consumer law and their own agreement.
The AA's Smart Care service is not fit for purpose. They:
- Ignored every email from me
- Broke promises to call back
- Initially misrepresented what I’d be refunded
- Contradicted their own terms and conditions
- Failed to notify me directly of any invoice amendments
- Left me to do all the chasing
For a brand that prides itself on trust (apparently), reliability, and roadside expertise — this was nothing short of a customer service failure from start to finish.
Avoid AA Smart Care. There are far better-run garages and services out there that will respect your time, your money, and the contract you agreed to.
Never again.
*** EDIT - In response to The AA's comment below***
Thanks for the reply – though it doesn’t inspire much confidence.
The fact remains: I already followed your process and submitted a formal complaint on the day of the failed service (27 June), followed by multiple chaser emails – none of which were ever acknowledged by The AA. No contact, no confirmation. Nothing.
The only reason this was resolved is because I made repeated contact and pushed for accountability. At no point did anyone from The AA proactively update me.
Your assurance that “our teams will reach out” remains to be seen. Based on my experience, I’ve no faith that your complaints process functions properly or treats customer concerns with any urgency.
I’ll await your response, but I won’t be holding my breath.
*** EDIT 16th August *** - Unsurprisingly - I never heard anything about this again, despite assurances the issue would be investigated and I'd be contacted, that never happened. I expected the AA's response was simply to save face and appear concerned/ interested to readers, and that they had no intention of investigating... and they've proved me right. Never, never again will I be giving them any business. Never. Absolute shambles.
June 27, 2025
Unprompted review