No refunds for fit
TLDR: avoid. AOCTW offer only store credit for issues of fit.
I wear M everywhere else so I naturally chose M here as well. Shirts ended up too tight at the abdomen and too broad at the shoulders. Customer service refuses to offer full refund for fitting issues. Notice their policy keeps referring to 'returns' (which are accepted) but not 'refunds'. What good is a store credit at a shirt store where the shirts do not fit me?
AVOID until such time as they revise what is an outdated policy for a virtual apparel store in 2025.
Edit: thank you for outing yourself as the Strike Anywhere team, another apparel website with no refunds for ill-fitting clothes that I will avoid. It also goes against your narrative that you are just "a small business trying to stay afloat."
Reply from Andoutcomethewolves
Thanks for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re sorry to hear the fit didn’t work out for you — sizing can definitely be tricky when shopping online.
Just to clarify, our policy does state that returns for fit or change-of-mind are eligible for store credit rather than a refund. This helps us keep our small business sustainable while still giving customers the option to exchange or pick something else that works better.
We totally understand your frustration if the sizing wasn’t right this time, and we’re always working on clearer size guides and fit info to help avoid situations like this in the future. If you’d like, our team can also help you find a better fit in another style using your measurements.
Appreciate your honesty, and we’ll take your feedback into account as we review our policies moving forward.
— The Strike Anywhere Team