MJ

Mr John Newman

United Kingdom

Reviews

Review of Tesco Insurance


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

A guaranteed quote was not in fact guaranteed

A couple of weeks before my car insurance was due for renewal, I received an online quote that clearly stated it was valid up to the expiry date. The day before the expiry, I set about going with the quote, only to find that the price had increased by around 10% (all the same details).
A series of conversations with Tesco revealed that in fact the quote was not guaranteed as the wording on it indicated.
Feeling misled, I decided to get the insurance elsewhere.

Update following Tesco response:
There is nothing to investigate - the facts are as I have described. I have already had several calls with CS & although they **eventually** agreed to honour the lower price they insisted that they were within their rights to change a price previously indicated as fixed. It's all a matter of trust.

September 11, 2025
Unprompted review

Reply from Tesco Insurance

Hi John, Thanks for taking the time to share your feedback. We strive to offer our customers competitive prices across all our products. We’re sorry that hasn’t been your experience, if you’d like to contact our customer service team we can investigate this for you.

Review of Cotton Traders


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Quick to charge, very slow to refund.

Charge you immediately you place an order (best practice is not to charge until the order is despatched), but refunds can take a couple of weeks, often blamed on the courier........

In reply to CT's response...... at 07/06/25, still no sign of a refund despite the assurance.

10/06/25 - No further information & still no sign of a refund
11/06/25 - Refund at last arrived. So in summary.....I was charged immediately for an order i was not allowed to cancel minutes after I placed it & as instructed, I refused delivery. However, it still took 3 weeks to issue the refund. Not exactly impressive.

May 22, 2025
Unprompted review

Reply from Cotton Traders

Hi Mr Newman
Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We're so sorry to hear about the issues with our payment and refund process. We'll look into these concerns with our team and the courier. Thanks for taking the time to leave your feedback.
Kind regards
Lisa P

Review of Cotton Traders


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Cannot cancel an order

I raised an order by mistake and rang immediately to cancel it. However it takes 20 mins for orders to appear on their system. Called back 20 mins later to be told there is no cancellation facility.....I have to wait for delivery and then return the items. How ridiculous.
In response to CT's reply:
1) At 5pm today, Evri says they are expecting my order within 48 hours, so the story about instant despatch from the DC is nonsense. If customer services can't see an order for at least 20 mins, nor can the DC.
2) No other online retailer I have ever used has had such an inflexible cancellation policy. Amazon sets the standard.
3) I expect to see a full refund (including postage) and no charge for the return......we'll see.
What a paraphernalia for something that could have been nipped in the bud, not to mention the environmental impact of shipping to and fro unnecessarily.

May 22, 2025
Unprompted review

Reply from Cotton Traders

Hi Mr Newman
We can understand your frustration with the cancellation process. Unfortunately due to the speed customers are expecting their orders to arrive , we have to move extremely quickly to get our orders picked, packed and dispatched as soon as possible. Online orders go directly to our Distribution Centre and get picked straight away. We regret that sometimes we are unable to cancel online orders immediately .We are sorry that you have to wait for delivery before returning the items. If you are at home when your delivery arrives , you can refuse it and the Evri courier will ensure it gets returned to us as soon as possible. We apologise for any inconvenience caused.
Kind regards
Lisa P

Review of Switcheroo

Review of Octopus Energy


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

It's a shame there is no zero

It's a shame there is no zero. Despite the pride they say they have in their standards of customer service, I have always found it appalling - polite, but appalling. To prove how bad, I have now received 2 amounts of compensation, one enforced by the Ombudsman.
They have now started using a child's version of AI, so it will only get worse. So, no, I would not recommend to friends & family.......or even my worst enemy.

June 6, 2024

Reply from Octopus Energy

Hi John,

Thanks so much for your review on Trustpilot, we really appreciate all feedback so we can work on making things better for our customers.

I am sorry that you do not agree with your change in direct debit. This is a payment adequacy review, which we need to carry out for customers to ensure that their accounts are well looked after and are not falling behind.

I have popped over an email so we can go over this in more detail.

Many thanks,
George

Review of Hayloft


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Read the small print (if there is any)

The order confirmation dated 21/04 stated that my order would be despatched by 24/04, but by 30/04 had still not arrived. The response to my email query on 30/04 promised a response within 7 days & gave me a "request number". Having followed it up and still heard nothing by 10/05, I rang the CS dept. to be told my order was not "scheduled" for despatch until July!!!!. There was no mention of this on the order confirmation (nor in the original ad as far as I can recall) and it didn't stop them debiting my credit card on the day I placed the order - not illegal but certainly sharp practice - charging customers when orders are physically despatched is considered industry best practice.
No explanation for no response to my email queries
Requested a refund, would not use again.

April 21, 2024
Unprompted review

Reply from Hayloft

Good morning

We are sorry to hear of your disappointment with both the communication and service received following your order. Please do contact us at evieg@hayloft.co.uk if you would like to discuss this further.

Kind regards Evie

Review of Autoglass®


Rated 3 out of 5 stars

Impossible communication

I needed to contact the depot, but the only phone number provided is to the call centre who claimed they had no way of passing a message on. Total nonsense, as the depot had called me earlier but from an undeclared "private number". Most unhelpful.

From the Autoglass response, I now have to email someone else to repeat what I have already said. What's the point?

February 6, 2024

Reply from Autoglass®

We are sorry to hear that our service did not meet your expectations. Please email customer.services@autoglass.co.uk to explain the issue (using your vehicle registration or booking reference number as the email subject), and you will be contacted to discuss this further. Kind regards, Kylie

Review of Wilko


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Having a laugh - 10 days for a refund?????

An online order for 4 of an item. Order accepted & payment taken almost instantly. Next day, order cancelled (by them), with no explanation, but advice the refund will take 5 days – all contained in what was obviously an off-the-shelf response.
Clearly their stock records and their inventory control process are rubbish, which I mentioned in my complaint. Their response was yet another off-the-shelf message full of clichés – it could not have sounded less sincere – and apparently the refund might take 10 days.
They clearly have no real interest in customer service and are content to just go through the motions. I for one, will as they say be voting with my feet – never again.

July 4, 2023
Unprompted review

Review of Prudential Plc


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Having a dialogue is impossible........

Having a dialogue is impossible. They are always "experiencing a higher number of phone calls than usual", or passing your secure message on to the "relevant dept" who "will be in touch shortly". Delays on the phone of up to an hour are not uncommon & the relevant dept never does message back. If you are lucky, whatever they are doing for you might be trundling on, albeit slowly, in the background, but don't expect to be kept informed of progress & don't expect any deadlines to be met. You can raise a formal complaint, but this process is just as poor as all the others - uninformative, slow & vague. Heaven help anyone who needs money out urgently as they only have one pace & the "rules" have clearly not been designed with customer service in mind.
I have honestly never come anything quite so poor.

July 5, 2023
Unprompted review

Review of Marks and Spencer


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Email communication is a time consuming nightmare

Part of my order is long overdue and nobody has the sense to realise by now it has been lost in transit. Bad enough, but email communication with the customer service dept is a nightmare. The published address returns a server error. When you find the contact form, all you get back is a standard letter based on the topic, not specifically addressed to your issue. After trying other routes you might be lucky enough to get an email response, but sent from a no-reply address, so you cannot respond.
Why they don't just provide a single email address that allows a normal conversation is beyond me.

November 5, 2022
Unprompted review

Review of April King Legal


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Not at all what one would expect from the legal profession

AK’S responses to criticisms posted here are at least consistent – their service standards are exemplary and any customer that feels otherwise is patently mistaken and only has themselves to blame. Their reaction to what I have to say here is therefore extremely predictable. I have genuinely been astonished at the attitude their anonymous, so-called “Legal Team” have taken, particularly coming from such an estimable profession. It strikes me that it is one of these organisations that insist you play by their rules and take great exception if you do not. If you do, the service would appear to be good, but God-forbid if you don’t.
Looking back, there were some ominous early warning signs when it appeared that any contact outside of what they deemed as absolutely necessary was chargeable over and above the quoted price, but at that stage I was too far down the road to do anything other than battle on.
The issue now is their unilateral decision to introduce a subscription-based club as the only means of gaining access to one’s documents, without providing a cost-free opt-out and I am not surprised to see that there are others who have found their approach and tactics unacceptable, bordering on exploitative. New customers presumably are told about these new costs and have the option to go elsewhere if they wish, but of course existing customers do not. One might reasonably regard this as sharp-practice, but AK does not like this expression so let’s just describe it as opportunistic. In my experience & by my standards, they have shown a lack of integrity, which of course they dispute.
I believe that the introduction of these new charges in this manner is outside the deal I had with them and simply wish to take my documents back & end the relationship. I am prepared to pay a postage cost or collect them personally, but not pay an additional, large “exit fee”, never previously mentioned. However, in expressing my displeasure at effectively being blackmailed, but nevertheless trying to reach a quick resolution, I have been met with some surprising accusations:
1) I am “unprofessional”, despite not claiming to be a professional. There is a certain irony here.
2) I am guilty of harassment – I’m not sure who I have harassed as all of the correspondence is anonymous – always a cause for suspicion. All I want is my documents back when it appears they are being held hostage.
As it currently stands, I have been given a “final warning” (no idea what that means) and they are refusing to deal with me any longer, only my legal representatives. They have denied me the opportunity to represent myself, a right afforded in both courts and tribunals. All their correspondence is labelled “not for publication or dissemination” – so clearly they don’t want anyone else to see their intimidation and threats. It is plain that the nameless staff in the “Legal Team” have very little legal training and even less in the art of customer service.
I suspect the staff that respond to the criticisms here are the same staff that caused them, so again, they are just a tad biased. We’ll no doubt see. It will also interesting to see the nature of their complaints process (probably handled by the same team) and which regulatory bodies are involved.
Would I recommend to my friends and family? No, one can only speak as one finds.

Update: Worth noting that AK’s response does not contest any of the issues I have raised. Persistence is sadly necessary to counter the prevarication (remembering the documents are rightfully mine) which has been frustrating, but no fair-minded person would apply any more extreme interpretation, of that I am sure.
They will of course exploit the leverage that they think holding original documents gives them. So I’ll update further when they address the outstanding issues. Readers here can judge for themselves which version of events they wish to believe.

In terms of their “business model” mentioned elsewhere in this thread, it rather sounds like the legal advisors we meet are actually self-employed, which allows AK to sidestep any culpability for incorrect legal advice. However, if the dispute is to do with the company’s commercial practices, there is no independent recourse – you can complain to them and you can appeal their decision, but only to them. Beyond that, there is nowhere to go.
Further Update: One month on and there is stalemate. AKL refuses to return my documents & has taken the highly unprofessional decision not to even attempt to find a solution. Given they cannot dispose of the documents, I have no idea what leverage they think they have & what they think the end-point will be. Ho hum. My advice to others would be to use a traditional solicitor, even if it costs a wee bit more.

September 30, 2022
Unprompted review

Reply from April King Legal

Mr Newman
Our Head Office Legal Team consists of senior specialist lawyers. Your emails have been persistently aggressive and this is completely unacceptable behaviour, not just by our standards but by that of the courts.

Review of Angling Direct


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

A wrong item was shipped which I…

A wrong item was shipped which I notified immediately. 2 weeks later I'm still waiting for the item I actually ordered with no idea how much longer it will take. Slow Internal procedures clearly get in the way of customer service.
Response to AD Reply:
Not the full story. My first notification of the error was ignored - it was the 2nd that eventually made some progress. I have run a number of large on-line warehouses and know exactly how long these "investigations" take - a phone call, that's how long. To make matters worse, the product I wanted was available under a different SKU that could have been re-shipped immediately, but it took ME to point this out. Otherwise, I might still be waiting now.

August 16, 2022
Unprompted review

Reply from Angling Direct

Hello, thank you for your feedback. I am sorry to see you have left a 1-star review on this occasion.

I can see that this was dealt with by one of our advisors who took all the necessary investigations to try get this resolved as best as possible. We do usually need photos of what you have received to check this in the warehouse which prevents and avoids the same incorrect item being shipped.

I am sorry to see this took longer than usual but I am glad that a replacement was dispatched once this had been looked into.

Sorry for any inconvenience caused.

Kind regards, Chanel.

Review of Greensleeves Lawn Care


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

It's a shame really

It's a shame really. After a promising start a couple of years ago, the condition of the lawn has deteriorated considerably over the past year. Someone turns up every few months, spreads some chemicals and sends us a bill. Clearly they have not been working for a while but the strategy appears just to continue as is. We have ended the arrangement for a re-think.

September 19, 2021
Unprompted review

Reply from Greensleeves Lawn Care

Hi John, we are really disappointed with your comments and that your law has seemingly deteriorated. If you could please provide us with some more information we will look into this for you, please contact greensleeves@greensleeves-uk.com. Thank you.

Review of Sykes Holiday Cottages


Rated 2 out of 5 stars

No improvement year on year sadly

No substantial improvement year on year sadly. Still the standard auto response to emails claiming to be very busy, when by now it should be obvious many more staff are needed. Responses are at best slow, at worse non-existent. They clearly regard their customers as the owners rather than us holiday makers which reflects itself in their attitude to perfectly reasonable requests. It strikes me that they are happy to deal with relatively straightforward queries, but totally uncompromising when it comes to anything that requires a bit more effort on their part.
Have also come across "rules" the owners know nothing about

April 24, 2021
Unprompted review

Review of WatercoolingUK

Review of Iceland Foods


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Non existent customer service.

Home delivery: A simple issue of an unreasonable substitute in a home delivery order. Any other chain would have dealt with it 24 hrs. With Iceland however, 2 months on & still not resolved. Customer Service is useless. They have stopped taking phone calls and don't respond to emails or the contact form on their website. Clearly the do not care how many customers they lose and gamble on nobody taking out small claims proceedings for what is probably just a few quid. Ironically, this post will be sent to the same email address that never responds - that shows the level of interest they really have in customer service.

July 6, 2020
Unprompted review

Review of Greensleeves Lawn Care


Rated 3 out of 5 stars

At least now they are back on schedule…

At least now they are back on schedule and turning up on the day they should. It would however help to have an indication of time of arrival - it is not right to ask customers to leave their property unlocked all day.

October 26, 2019
Unprompted review

Reply from Greensleeves Lawn Care

Hi John, we are so sorry to hear that you feel we have not been communicating properly regarding arrival time. A time can definitely be catered for if discussed. Please feel free to contact us on 0808 100 1413 to discuss this further

Review of Hoseasons


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Catastrophic error, no regrets on their part

Had a dog-friendly lodge booked for months for a family holiday & had paid all the premiums accordingly & had the booking confirmed. 2 weeks out we called to check on something & by pure chance found it was not in fact dog friendly - their mistake not ours. All they would offer was a much smaller lodge but only at its normal price. A great solution for them leaving all the problems with us. And that was it. So we took a refund and will never use them again. I wonder what would have happened if we'd discovered the problem when we arrived.

July 21, 2019
Unprompted review

Review of Greensleeves Lawn Care


Rated 1 out of 5 stars

This is my 3rd review on this shower…

This is my 3rd review on this shower and after each post the situation has become worse not better, so I still have the original problem from February. This is despite continued assurances from them all of which have come to absolutely nothing - they do not even return phone calls as promised. Their replies to these posts suggest they have done more than they really have, so don't believe them.

May 30, 2019
Unprompted review

Reply from Greensleeves Lawn Care

Hi John, we're not quite sure what you're referring to as we don't have any services relating to showers, but would be more than happy to talk to you if you would find that helpful. Feel free to ring our offices on 0808 100 1413.

Review of Greensleeves Lawn Care


Rated 2 out of 5 stars

Greensleeves' response to original review

Greensleeves' response to my last review is a mile off the reality. My last treatment was due in Feb & nobody turned then or since. Over the past 3 months I have offered 20 dates all of which have been allowed to pass. Greensleeves by contrast have offered just a few, one of which was suitable but then they changed their mind. Nothing has happened for weeks. I was told I should have been contacted by a senior manager but that hasn't happened either, so I have no idea what they are up to.

May 25, 2019
Unprompted review

Reply from Greensleeves Lawn Care

We’re sorry to read this John, we will ensure the manager contacts you on Tuesday.